• New Releases
  • Seforim
    • Gemara & Mishna
    • Halacha & Minhagim
    • Siddurim & Tefillah
    • Machzorim
    • Tehillim
    • Tanach & Chumash
    • Mussar, Machshava & Chassidus
    • Moadim
    • Yiddish Seforim
    • Antique Leather
  • English Books
    • Jewish Thought
    • Torah & Tefillah
    • Halacha
    • Holidays
    • Novels
    • Biographies
    • History
    • Parenting & Life Events
    • Self Help
    • Cookbooks
  • Kids Books
    • Babies & Toddlers
    • Young Readers
    • Teens
    • Comics
    • Short Stories
    • Stories of Tzaddikim
    • Parsha Books
    • Series Books
    • Yiddish Kids Books
    • Children's Siddurim
  • Toys & Games
    • Toys
    • Board Games
    • Card Games
    • Puzzles
    • Educational Games
    • Torah & Judaica Toys
    • Talking Toys
    • Arts & Crafts
    • Coloring Books
    • Chanukah Toys & Crafts
  • Holidays
    • Yamim Noraim
    • Succos
    • Chanukah
    • Purim
    • Pesach
    • Shavuos
    • Three Weeks & Tisha B'Av
    • Yom Tov Seforim
  • Shabbos & Yom Tov
    • Candlesticks
    • Candelabras
    • Candles & Oil
    • Shabbos Lamps
    • Kiddush Cups
    • Challah Boards
    • Challah Covers
    • Havdalah Sets
    • Washing Cups
    • Set Your Table
  • Judaica & Home
    • Mezuzahs
    • Washing Cups
    • Tzedakah Boxes
    • Shtenders
    • Artwork & Frames
    • Kosher Kitchen
    • Wedding
  • Tallis, Tzitzis & Yarmulkes
    • Talleisim & Atarahs
    • Tzitzis
    • Yarmulkes
    • Tallis & Tefillin Bags
    • Gartels
    • Kittels
    • Garment Accessories
  • Music & Media
    • All Music
    • Chassidic Music
    • Children's Music
    • Classes & Shiurim
    • Concerts
    • Videos & Plays
    • Music on USB
    • Digital Downloads
  • Gifts
    • Chanukah Gifts
    • Gift Cards
    • Bar Mitzvah Gifts
    • Bat Mitzvah Gifts
    • Wedding Gifts
    • Upsherin Gifts
    • Shabbos Table Gifts
    • Judaica Gifts
    • Personalized Gifts
    • Custom Seforim Stamps
  • School Books
  1. Home
  2. Blog

Where to Buy a Menorah: How to Choose and Why Families Shop at 1800 Eichlers

Published October 25, 2026

Add 1800Eichlers as a preferred source on Google

Where to buy a menorah is one of the first Chanukah questions families ask each fall. This guide compares the three main places to shop, gives a 10-point checklist, and shows which menorah fits each person in your home. 1800 Eichlers is the online store of Eichler's of Boro Park, 5004 13th Avenue, Brooklyn, NY 11219.

Quick Answer

You can buy a menorah at a Judaica store in person, at an online Judaica store, or at a general marketplace. A Judaica store is the most reliable choice, because its range is built around halacha (Jewish law): eight lights in a straight row at one height, with the shamash (helper light) set apart, as Chabad.org explains.

Key Observations

  • General marketplaces mix decorative and seven-branch pieces with Chanukah menorahs, so check every listing.
  • Check three things first: a straight row, one even height, and a shamash set apart.
  • Olive oil is the preferred fuel, and standard 30-minute candles are too short for Friday.
  • Chanukah 2026 begins on Friday, December 4, so nights one and eight both fall on Erev Shabbos.
  • 1800 Eichlers carries about 150 menorahs and lighting items, with free Brooklyn pickup on eligible items and US and global shipping.

Here is how the three places to buy a menorah compare at a glance.

Where to buyBest forCheck before you pay
Judaica store, in personSeeing the size and weight, asking questions, same-day pickupStore hours and stock close to Chanukah
Online Judaica storeWide range, matching candles and oil, shipping to your doorDimensions, candle size and the delivery options at checkout
General marketplace or big-box storeLast-minute buys and decorative piecesStraight row, even height, and eight lights plus a shamash

Want to compare styles and materials first? Our menorah buying guide covers menorah types, metals and oil versus candles in depth.

In this guide

  1. Quick Answer
  2. Where to buy a menorah
  3. What makes a menorah kosher?
  4. 10-point buying checklist
  5. Oil or candle menorah?
  6. What size to buy
  7. Menorah by need
  8. Electric menorahs
  9. When to buy for Chanukah 2026
  10. Why families shop at 1800 Eichlers
  11. Menorah buying FAQs
  12. Sources

Where to buy a menorah: Judaica store, online or marketplace?

The three places to buy a menorah are a Judaica store you can visit, an online Judaica store, and a general marketplace or big-box store. Each one trades off selection, halacha guidance, help choosing, and pickup or shipping. A Judaica store is a shop for Jewish ritual items, books and gifts, such as menorahs, Shabbos candlesticks and seforim (holy books).

Buying a menorah at a Judaica store in person

A Judaica store lets you hold the menorah, feel its weight and see the finish before you pay. You can ask which candles fit and take the menorah home the same day. Go a few weeks early, since popular styles can sell out. The catch is location: Judaica stores cluster in Jewish neighborhoods, so families in smaller towns may have few or none nearby.

Buying a menorah from an online Judaica store

An online Judaica store gives you the widest range in one place, from silver and oil menorahs to children's designs. You can add candles, oil and a drip tray to the same order. You cannot hold the menorah, though, so read the dimensions and study the photos.

Buying a menorah at a general marketplace or big-box store

A general marketplace or big-box store may have a Hanukkah menorah for sale in late fall, which helps with a last-minute buy. Listings mix ritual menorahs with decorative pieces, and a menorah for sale there may not say whether its lights sit in a straight row.

The most common mistake, raised again in Jewish online forums, is buying a seven-branch menorah. A Chanukah menorah needs eight lights plus a shamash. When we read eight where-to-buy guides and shopping roundups in October 2026, none explained the straight-row rule, so do not expect a general listing to explain it either.

This table compares what you get from each type of store when you buy a menorah.

What you getJudaica store, in personOnline Judaica storeGeneral marketplace
Menorah selectionLimited by shelf spaceWide, many styles and makersWide, mixed with decor
Kosher layout guidanceAsk staff face to faceProduct details and online helpOften not stated
Help choosingIn personChat or customer serviceMostly buyer reviews
Matching candles, oil and traysUsually in the same shopSame order, same cartVaries by seller
Pickup and shippingTake it home todayShipping, plus store pickup where offeredVaries by seller
Best forSeeing it firstRange and convenienceLast-minute or decor

In short, buy a menorah in person to see the finish or when you need it today, and buy online for range and for candles that fit in the same order. Shopping for more than a menorah? Our Hanukkah Judaica shopping guide lists what a home needs for all eight nights.

What makes a menorah kosher for Chanukah?

A kosher Chanukah menorah has eight lights in a straight row at the same height, plus a shamash set apart from the row. The Rema's note in Shulchan Aruch, Orach Chaim 671:4 says to set the lights in a row and not in a circle.

The Shulchan Aruch is the code of Jewish law, and the Rema wrote notes on it. He asks for the lights בשורה (b'shurah), "in a row," because a circle looks like a מדורה (medurah), "a bonfire," not separate lights. For the same reason, he says not to stick wax candles together.

  • Eight lights in one straight row. No circles, curves or zigzags.
  • One even height. The Chabad.org Chanukah Guide says the lights should be in a straight row and of equal height.
  • A shamash set apart. The shamash stands higher, lower or to the side, so nobody counts it as one of the eight. In Orach Chaim 673:1, the Rema says to make the shamash taller.
  • Separate flames. Separate candlesticks are allowed, since each light stands on its own.

Customs differ on some details. Chabad.org notes that an even slant is also acceptable, and families differ on where the shamash sits. If a design looks unusual, ask your Rav before you buy.

What should you check before you buy a menorah?

Before you buy a menorah, check the layout first, then the fuel, the size and who will light it. The 10 points below combine the halacha basics from the Shulchan Aruch and Chabad.org with practical checks, such as candle fit and window space. Keep the list open while you shop, in a store or online.

  1. Straight row. All eight lights sit in one line, never a circle or a curve.
  2. Even height. The eight cups or holders are level with each other.
  3. Shamash apart. The ninth light is clearly higher, lower or off to the side.
  4. Room between flames. Each flame stands alone and does not merge with the next one.
  5. The fuel you will use. Glass cups for olive oil, or holders sized for standard Chanukah candles.
  6. Friday burn time. The Chabad.org guide says standard 30-minute candles cannot be used on Friday, so pick cups that take longer candles or more oil.
  7. Space where you light. Measure the windowsill, doorway table or tray before you order.
  8. No backsplash for a window. For a windowsill facing the street, Chabad.org's Chanukah laws say to use a menorah without a backsplash, so the lights stay visible.
  9. A steady, heat-safe base. The menorah should stand firm on a fireproof surface, away from curtains and out of small children's reach.
  10. The person lighting it. A child needs something sturdy, and the Chabad.org guide says children should be encouraged to light their own. Our guide to how many menorahs your family needs explains the custom.

Should you buy an oil menorah or a candle menorah?

An oil menorah is the preferred choice if your family can manage it, because the Rema rules that olive oil is the choicest fuel for the mitzvah. A candle menorah is fully acceptable and simpler for many homes. The Chabad.org guide lists cotton wicks in olive oil, or beeswax candles, as the ideal ways to light.

In the Rema's words, שמן זית (shemen zayis), "olive oil," is מצוה מן המובחר (mitzvah min hamuvchar), "the choicest way to do the mitzvah." Here is what each type asks of you:

  • Oil menorah: needs glass cups, wicks and oil. A kriegel, a small jug for pouring oil, makes filling easier, and pre-filled oil cups skip the pouring.
  • Candle menorah: quick to set up and easy for children, but check that standard Chanukah candles fit the holders snugly.
  • Either type: a drip tray under the menorah catches wax or oil and protects the table.

Birthday candles burn for only a few minutes, so they are too short for lights that must last at least half an hour after nightfall.

What size menorah should you buy?

The right menorah size is the one that fits where you light and holds enough fuel. Chabad.org's Chanukah laws place the menorah more than three handbreadths above the floor and preferably below ten, which matches Shulchan Aruch, Orach Chaim 671:6. A handbreadth is roughly the width of a hand.

  • Windowsill: measure the depth as well as the width, and keep the flames clear of glass and blinds.
  • Doorway: Chabad custom is to set the menorah on a chair or small stand inside the doorway, opposite the mezuzah.
  • Several menorahs: plan space so each one stands apart, since the Rema in 671:2 says each person should light in a separate spot.

Which menorah should you buy for each person in your home?

The best menorah for each person depends on who lights it and where. A family's main menorah can be silver or oil, a child's menorah should be sturdy, and outdoor or doorway lighting needs a glass box against the wind. The table below matches common needs to real menorahs and accessories at 1800 Eichlers.

NeedWhat to look forExample at 1800 Eichlers
Main family menorah with oilOil cups in a straight row, shamash set apart, a drip traySilver Plated Oil Menorah
Classic candle menorah or a giftHolders that fit standard Chanukah candles, a solid baseClassic Menorah with Silver
Modern look for a new homeA clean, even row, and no backsplash if it goes in a windowMenorah Lucite
A child's own menorahMetal that will not shatter, low and stableTin Menorah with Painting
Outdoor or doorway lightingA glass box that shields the flames from windGlass Menorah Box for Outdoor Lighting
Menorahs for a school, shul or groupMatching pieces in quantity1800 Eichlers bulk orders

Check each product page for size, layout and materials before you order.

What menorah should you buy as a gift?

A menorah makes a lasting gift for a new couple, a new home or a bar mitzvah. Chabad.org says it is preferred to buy the most beautiful menorah within your means, and silver if possible. Pick a design that meets the layout rules, so the gift gets lit, not just displayed.

Can you buy an electric menorah for Chanukah?

You can buy an electric menorah for decoration or a window display, but it should not replace the menorah you light. Chabad.org explains that, in the view of many authorities, an electric bulb lacks the fuel, wick and fire of the menorah in the Beis HaMikdash (the Holy Temple), so one may not fulfill the mitzvah with it.

Chabad.org suggests keeping an electric menorah lit in your window, as long as you also light a regular one. If a flame is truly not possible, ask your rabbi about a battery-powered light, used without the brachos (blessings). For the full halacha, see our guide to electric and LED menorahs.

When should you buy a menorah for Chanukah 2026?

The best time to buy a menorah for Chanukah 2026 is by mid-November. Chanukah begins at sundown on Friday, December 4, 2026, and ends at nightfall on Saturday, December 12, according to Hebcal. Because the first night is Erev Shabbos, the menorah is lit that afternoon, before the Shabbos candles.

The eighth candle, on Friday, December 11, is also lit on Erev Shabbos, so two nights need longer candles or extra oil. Use this plan:

  1. Early November: choose the menorah and measure where it will stand.
  2. Mid-November: order candles or oil, wicks and a drip tray that fit it.
  3. Late November: set it up, test the candle fit, and set aside longer candles for both Fridays.
  4. Week of Chanukah: pick up any last items in person, such as extra candles or wicks.

For the date of every night, see our Hanukkah 2026 calendar.

Why do families shop for menorahs at 1800 Eichlers?

Families shop for menorahs at 1800 Eichlers because the online range comes from a real Judaica store in Brooklyn. 1800 Eichlers is the online store of the Boro Park store at 5004 13th Avenue, and it describes itself as "the largest Judaica retailer anywhere in the world." The Chanukah range has about 300 items.

Here is what 1800 Eichlers offers when you buy a menorah, based on the store's own details.

What 1800 Eichlers offersHow it helps you buy a menorah
About 150 menorahs and lighting itemsCompare oil, candle, modern, children's and outdoor styles in one place
About 150 Chanukah candle and oil itemsBuy candles, oil and wicks for your menorah in the same order
Brands such as Rite Lite, Ner Mitzvah, Waterdale Collection, A&M Judaica, Art Judaica, Cazenove Judaica, Hazorfim, iKippah and Boker-Tov ShalomChoose from many makers and styles
Free in-store pickup and local delivery on eligible items, shown at checkoutCollect in Brooklyn, or have it brought to your door locally
Free US shipping above the minimum shown at checkout, plus global shippingOrder from anywhere in the US or abroad
Eichler's Assistant chatGet help finding the right menorah, candles or oil
Bulk orders and a gift registryBuy for a school or shul, or add a menorah to a registry
Visa, Mastercard, Discover and American ExpressPay with the card you already use

Menorah buying FAQs

Where can I buy a menorah near me?

The closest place to buy a menorah is usually a local Judaica store, often found in Jewish neighborhoods. If you live in Brooklyn, 1800 Eichlers offers free in-store pickup on eligible items at its 13th Avenue store. If no store is nearby, an online Judaica store can ship a menorah to you in the US or abroad.

Is a seven-branch menorah kosher for Chanukah?

No. A seven-branch menorah follows the seven-lamp menorah described in the Torah, in Exodus 25:37. A Chanukah menorah needs eight lights, because the Shulchan Aruch says to add one light each night until the eighth, plus a separate shamash. So the menorah you buy needs nine places in all.

How many candles do I need for one menorah?

One menorah needs 44 candles for all eight nights of Chanukah. That is 36 candles for the lights, one on the first night and one more each night after, plus 8 for the shamash. In 2026, plan longer candles or extra oil for both Fridays, December 4 and December 11.

How much should I spend on a menorah?

Spend what fits your budget, because a simple menorah with a straight row and an even height is fully kosher. Chabad.org says it is preferred to buy the most beautiful menorah within your means. Leave some budget for candles or oil, wicks and a drip tray, which you will need every year.

Sources

  • Shulchan Aruch, Orach Chaim 671, Sefaria
  • Shulchan Aruch, Orach Chaim 673, Sefaria
  • What Constitutes a Kosher Chanukah Menorah?, Chabad.org
  • Chanukah Guide, Chabad.org
  • Chanukah Laws (Dinim), Chabad.org
  • Why Can't I Use an Electric Menorah?, Chabad.org
  • Chanukah 2026, Hebcal
  • Exodus 25:37, Sefaria

How we created this guide: We researched it from the sources listed above, read the pages that rank for where to buy a menorah, and reviewed it against current 1800 Eichlers products. A person checks the facts before publishing.

Ready to choose? Browse oil, candle, modern and children's menorahs in the 1800 Eichlers menorah collection, and add candles or oil that fit before the first night on Friday, December 4.

  • Terms of Use
  • Privacy Policy
  • Shipping Policy
  • Return Policy
  • About
  • Blog
  • Contact Us
  • Store Hours
  • Store Address
  • Bulk Orders