What Is a Chanukah Menorah?
The Chanukah menorah (also called a chanukiah or chanukiyah) is a nine-branched candelabra used during the eight-day Jewish festival of Chanukah. Eight branches hold the Chanukah lights, one for each night of the holiday, and a ninth branch holds the shamash, the helper candle used to light all the others.
The nine-branched Chanukah menorah is distinct from the seven-branched menorah (the Temple Menorah), which is a symbol of the Jewish people but is not used for Chanukah lighting. The Chanukah menorah commemorates the miracle of the oil: when the Maccabees recaptured and rededicated the Temple in Jerusalem in 165 BCE, they found only enough ritually pure olive oil to light the Temple Menorah for one day. The oil miraculously burned for eight days, long enough to prepare a new supply. The Chanukah lights reenact and publicize this miracle every year.
The full Chanukah menorah collection, in every style and material, is at 1800 Eichlers Chanukah menorahs, 5004 13th Ave, Borough Park, Brooklyn.
Oil vs Candles: The Halachic Priority
The most practically important question for buying a Chanukah menorah is whether you plan to use oil or candles. This choice affects which type of menorah you need.
Why Olive Oil Is Preferred
The Rama (Rabbi Moshe Isserles, the primary Ashkenazic halachic authority) rules in Orach Chayim 673:1 that the mitzvah min hamuvchar, the preferred way to perform the mitzvah, is to use olive oil for the Chanukah lights. The Aruch HaShulchan gives three reasons: olive oil produces a clear and pure light, it draws well into the wick, and most significantly, the miracle in the Temple occurred specifically with olive oil. Using the same material for the annual commemoration adds a layer of meaning that other fuels do not carry.
If olive oil is not available, the halacha calls for other oils that produce a clear and pure flame. If oil is not available at all, the common Ashkenazic practice is to use wax or paraffin candles, whose flame is described as "pure and clean like that of oil." The jellied olive oil Chanukah candles at 1800 Eichlers combine the halachic preference for olive oil with the convenience of pre-portioned solid gel: no measuring, no spilling, and the preferred fuel in a practical format.
One Material Per Menorah
A practical halachic rule that many people are not aware of: all the candles or oil cups in a single menorah should use the same fuel. Rav Moshe Feinstein zt"l ruled that mixing oil lights and wax candles in the same menorah diminishes the beauty of the mitzvah, because the different types of flame create an uneven appearance. Different oils may be used together (since the light looks similar), but oil and candles should not be mixed in the same menorah. Where multiple menorahs are being lit by different family members, one may use oil in one menorah and candles in another.
Which Menorahs Work for Oil vs Candles
Oil menorahs have small cups or glass holders designed to contain liquid oil and a wick. They require a little more preparation (measuring oil, placing the wick) but are the halachically preferred format. Candle menorahs have standard candle holders that fit the small colored Chanukah candles sold as 44-packs. They are simpler to use and widely available. Many modern menorahs are designed for either format, with holders wide enough for candles and deep enough to accept oil cups as an insert. Check product descriptions carefully to confirm which format a specific menorah accommodates. The full menorah and candle selection is at 1800 Eichlers menorahs and 1800 Eichlers candles.
The 15 Menorah Materials Ranked: What Halacha Says
Rabbi Avraham Azulaiy, in his Chesed LeAvraham, ranks 15 types of materials from most to least preferable for the Chanukah menorah. This ranking is based on the principle that one should beautify the mitzvah (hiddur mitzvah) with the finest vessel one can reasonably afford.
Gold is the highest-ranked material, as it is the most precious. Silver is the second-highest and is explicitly recommended in the halachic literature as attainable for most households: the Kitzur Shulchan Aruch (139:5) and other authorities write that a person who can afford it should use a silver menorah, as it is not an unreasonable expense relative to the beauty it adds to the mitzvah. After silver come copper and other metals in descending order, followed by glass, tin, iron, and then wood. Earthenware (clay or ceramic) is specifically noted as something to avoid reusing, because an earthenware vessel that has held a single night's oil is considered old and unpleasant, and using it again is considered disrespectful to the mitzvah. Metal and glass menorahs may be cleaned and reused each night.
The practical implication for buyers: a silver or silver-plated menorah is not just an aesthetic choice but a halachically elevated one. A wood and silver-plated wall menorah at 1800 Eichlers combines the elevated status of silver plating with the practical format of a wall-mounted piece that does not take table space.
Where to Place the Chanukah Menorah
The placement of the Chanukah menorah is not merely a decorative decision; it is part of the mitzvah itself. The primary obligation is pirsumei nisa, publicizing the miracle. The halacha specifies placement guidelines designed to maximize this publicizing function.
The Doorway Placement
The traditional placement for the Chanukah menorah is at the left side of the entrance to one's home, at the outer doorpost. This placement puts the menorah opposite the mezuzah (which is on the right doorpost), so that the person entering the home is surrounded on both sides by mitzvot. The menorah should be placed within approximately one handbreadth (tefach) of the outer doorpost, and at a height between approximately 3 and 10 tefachim from the ground (roughly knee height to shoulder height). This placement is preferred when it is safe to do so and when the menorah is visible from the public thoroughfare.
The Window Placement
In most contemporary households, placing a flame-burning menorah at an unprotected outdoor doorpost is not practical or safe. The widely accepted alternative is placing the menorah in a window that faces the public domain or street. The menorah should be positioned so the lights are visible from outside. If the window is more than 10 tefachim above the ground outside (approximately 80 centimeters), the primary placement benefit is reduced, though the practice remains meaningful.
When Safety Requires Indoor Placement
Where neither doorway nor window placement is safe or practical, the menorah may be placed anywhere indoors where the lights are visible to members of the household. In this case, the lights serve to publicize the miracle to the family rather than to passersby. Electric menorahs are specifically appropriate for situations where fire is not safe.
How Long Must the Chanukah Lights Burn?
The Chanukah lights must burn for at least 30 minutes after tzeis hakochavim (nightfall, when the stars come out). This means that when preparing an oil menorah, you should ensure each cup contains enough oil to burn for at least 30 minutes after the official nightfall of that night. Most standard Chanukah candles are sized to burn for approximately 30 to 45 minutes when lit at the correct time.
On the Shabbat of Chanukah (when Chanukah lights are lit before Shabbat candles, since Shabbat prohibits lighting fire after sunset), the menorah should have enough oil to burn from before sundown until at least 30 minutes after tzeis. This typically requires a larger quantity of oil than on regular nights, since the menorah must be lit earlier. The Ner Mitzvah brand, available through 1800 Eichlers from Ner Mitzvah, produces oil glass cups and paraffin chandles in pre-measured formats specifically calibrated for the correct burn durations.
Once the lights have burned for the required 30 minutes, they may be extinguished if necessary. Oil and wicks remaining after the required time are halachically designated for the mitzvah and should be burned after Chanukah rather than used for other purposes. Many families stipulate before Chanukah that leftover oil is not designated for the mitzvah, which removes this concern.
The Straight Branch vs Curved Branch Question
One of the more interesting debates in Chanukah menorah design concerns the shape of the branches: should they be straight (diagonal) or curved (arched)?
The curved, arched menorah shape is the one most commonly depicted in Jewish art, marketing, and merchandise. However, based on extensive research by the Lubavitcher Rebbe into historical and halachic sources, including the Rambam's (Maimonides') depiction of the Temple Menorah in his Mishneh Torah, the Rebbe concluded that the true shape of the Temple Menorah had straight, diagonal branches rather than curved arched ones. The curved shape on the Arch of Titus in Rome, which many people take as the authentic Temple Menorah, may actually depict a different menorah used as Roman propaganda after the Temple's destruction.
The Rebbe's recommendation was that when choosing a Chanukah menorah with branches, one should prefer the straight-branch (Rambam) format. Menorahs without branches at all (flat menorahs or row-style menorahs) are also fully acceptable. In practice, both styles are widely used across all communities, and the choice of curved vs. straight branches does not affect the validity of the lighting.
Every Chanukah Menorah Type: A Complete Guide
The menorah category at 1800 Eichlers covers every format and style, from the purely functional to the artistically extraordinary. Here is how to think about each type.
Classic Silver and Silver-Plated Menorahs
Silver and silver-plated menorahs are the most traditional and most halachically elevated format (second only to gold in the Chesed LeAvraham's ranking). They range from simple and elegant to highly ornate with decorative engraving, filigree work, or inlaid gemstones. A silver menorah purchased for a family's first home is often used for decades and becomes a central piece of Jewish family memory. It is appropriate as a wedding gift, a bar or bat mitzvah gift, or a housewarming gift for a Jewish household.
Silver-plated menorahs offer the elevated status of silver at a more accessible price point than sterling, making this format available to every household. The wood and silver-plated wall menorah at 1800 Eichlers combines the silver material preference with a space-saving wall format that includes the text of the Chanukah blessings printed on the back panel. This makes it ideal for apartments and smaller homes where table space is limited.
Bronze and Metal Menorahs
Bronze, brass, and nickel menorahs occupy the middle range of the Chesed LeAvraham's material hierarchy. They are durable, easy to clean, and available in a wide range of sizes and styles. A well-made bronze menorah develops a rich patina over years of use. This category includes the widest variety of designs: traditional, contemporary, Israeli artistic styles, and a range of sizes from compact travel menorahs to large statement pieces for a windowsill or mantle.
Designer and Artist Menorahs
Designer menorahs made by Israeli studios and Judaica artists bring gallery-quality craftsmanship to a ritual object. Yair Emanuel menorahs, available at 1800 Eichlers through the 1800 Eichlers Chanukah collection, are among the most distinctive in this category: brightly painted anodized aluminum with scenes of Jerusalem, pomegranates, birds, and floral designs that make the menorah as beautiful as a piece of wall art when not in use. These menorahs are particularly meaningful as gifts because they are artist-signed pieces that carry the creative identity of an Israeli craftsman alongside the mitzvah object.
Wall Menorahs
Wall menorahs are mounted on a decorative backing and hung on the wall rather than placed on a surface. They save table and windowsill space and can often be positioned to face the door or window as required by placement halacha. The backing typically displays the Hebrew text of the Chanukah blessings. Wall menorahs range from simple wooden formats through ornate silver-plated pieces to modern acrylic and metal artistic designs.
Children's Menorahs
Many families purchase an additional menorah for each child in the household, a widespread Ashkenazic custom (documented in the Rama, Orach Chayim 671:2). Children's menorahs come in playful shapes and formats: sports-themed, character-based, and LEGO-style building sets. The hand-painted baseball menorah at 1800 Eichlers is a perfect example: a fully functional Chanukah menorah in the shape of a baseball diamond, appropriate for any child who loves America's favorite pastime. Giving a child their own menorah connects the holiday to personal ownership and participation from a young age. For the full range of children's Chanukah items and toys alongside menorahs, see the 1800 Eichlers toys and games collection.
Electric Menorahs
Electric menorahs use LED or incandescent bulbs rather than flame. They do not fulfill the Chanukah lighting obligation in halacha (which requires an actual flame), but they serve several practical purposes: they can be displayed in windows in locations where open flames are not permitted (many apartment buildings, offices, and public spaces prohibit candles), they can be used for decorative display during the day after the actual menorah has been lit, and they can be used in households with fire safety concerns. Electric menorahs are particularly useful as a secondary display piece when the primary menorah is lit with oil or candles in a different location.
How to Choose the Right Menorah for Your Home
With hundreds of menorahs available at 1800 Eichlers, the right choice depends on four factors: your intended fuel (oil or candles), your placement (table, windowsill, or wall), your household's aesthetic preferences, and your budget or the occasion for the purchase.
For a first menorah for a new household or a housewarming gift, a silver-plated or nickel menorah in a classic style provides longevity, halachic preference, and broad aesthetic appeal. For a child's first menorah, a themed or playful design creates a personal connection to the holiday. For a family that wants the halachically preferred olive oil format with maximum convenience, an oil-ready menorah paired with pre-made olive oil cups or jellied olive oil candles is the most practical combination.
Size matters for placement: a menorah intended for a windowsill should fit the window ledge comfortably with all candles lit; a wall menorah needs clear wall space and should be far enough from adjacent surfaces to be safe. A travel menorah (compact, folding, or flat) is the right choice for Chanukah away from home.
For the full selection across all types, materials, and price points, visit 1800 Eichlers Chanukah menorahs.
Chanukah Menorah as a Gift
A Chanukah menorah is among the most meaningful Jewish gifts available, precisely because it is a ritual object used annually for a lifetime. Unlike a holiday decoration that is seasonal, a menorah is a halachically significant object that connects the recipient to the mitzvah of Chanukah every year for decades.
For a bar or bat mitzvah gift, a silver or sterling silver menorah marks the occasion with a piece of Judaica worthy of the milestone. For a wedding gift, a menorah given to the new household will be lit at the family's first Chanukah together and every Chanukah thereafter. For a new home, a menorah as a housewarming gift establishes the Jewish identity of the space from its first Chanukah. For any Jewish child, a themed personal menorah makes the holiday their own. For the complete Jewish gifts context including Chanukah and all lifecycle occasions, the 1800 Eichlers Judaica gifts collection covers every occasion and price point.
What Customers Say About 1800 Eichlers
Customers who shop for Chanukah menorahs and Judaica at 1800 Eichlers describe a store with the depth of selection and the staff knowledge that makes Chanukah preparation easier and more meaningful.
Louis R. on Yelp: "The Home Depot of Judaica in the USA. Excellent selection. The owner is always around and you can talk with him personally."
Edward Neiger on Google: "Really great selection, very friendly and knowledgeable staff and good pricing."
Julius Hersh on Google: "Great service, very helpful employees with great prices."
Jeroen Reuven B. on Yelp: "Basically a mahkollet for daily and fancier Judaica. Very good value and service."
A Google reviewer: "Love walking in there. Great service. Has everything I need and organized!"
A longtime customer on @1800eichlers Instagram: "Best store ever. Been ordering from 1800 Eichlers since the 80s!! Mazel tov!"
The store maintains 4.7 stars across 770 reviews. For Chanukah menorahs specifically, the staff at 1800 Eichlers can advise on oil vs. candle formats, the right size for your window or table, the material hierarchy in halacha, and the best gift menorah for any occasion or recipient.
Why Buy Your Chanukah Menorah from 1800 Eichlers
A menorah purchased from a Judaica store where the staff understands the halachic preference for olive oil, knows the material ranking from the Chesed LeAvraham, can advise on placement for pirsumei nisa, and can match the right menorah to a bar mitzvah gift vs. a child's first holiday vs. a family heirloom, is a more considered purchase than one from a general gift shop or seasonal retailer.
1800 Eichlers is the 1800 Eichlers on 13th Avenue in Borough Park, Brooklyn, founded in 1987 and serving the Jewish community's holiday needs for generations. The full Chanukah collection, including menorahs, candles, oil, wicks, dreidels, Chanukah gifts, and holiday Judaica, is at the 1800 Eichlers Chanukah collection.
Free US shipping on all orders over $69. Same-day delivery across the tri-state area. Price match guarantee. In-store pickup Sunday through Friday at 5004 13th Ave, Borough Park. Call (718) 874-9771 or WhatsApp 1-800-342-4537.