• New Releases
  • Seforim
    • Gemara & Mishna
    • Halacha & Minhagim
    • Siddurim & Tefillah
    • Machzorim
    • Tehillim
    • Tanach & Chumash
    • Mussar, Machshava & Chassidus
    • Moadim
    • Yiddish Seforim
    • Antique Leather
  • English Books
    • Jewish Thought
    • Torah & Tefillah
    • Halacha
    • Holidays
    • Novels
    • Biographies
    • History
    • Parenting & Life Events
    • Self Help
    • Cookbooks
  • Kids Books
    • Babies & Toddlers
    • Young Readers
    • Teens
    • Comics
    • Short Stories
    • Stories of Tzaddikim
    • Parsha Books
    • Series Books
    • Yiddish Kids Books
    • Children's Siddurim
  • Toys & Games
    • Toys
    • Board Games
    • Card Games
    • Puzzles
    • Educational Games
    • Torah & Judaica Toys
    • Talking Toys
    • Arts & Crafts
    • Coloring Books
    • Chanukah Toys & Crafts
  • Holidays
    • Yamim Noraim
    • Succos
    • Chanukah
    • Purim
    • Pesach
    • Shavuos
    • Three Weeks & Tisha B'Av
    • Yom Tov Seforim
  • Shabbos & Yom Tov
    • Candlesticks
    • Candelabras
    • Candles & Oil
    • Shabbos Lamps
    • Kiddush Cups
    • Challah Boards
    • Challah Covers
    • Havdalah Sets
    • Washing Cups
    • Set Your Table
  • Judaica & Home
    • Mezuzahs
    • Washing Cups
    • Tzedakah Boxes
    • Shtenders
    • Artwork & Frames
    • Kosher Kitchen
    • Wedding
  • Tallis, Tzitzis & Yarmulkes
    • Talleisim & Atarahs
    • Tzitzis
    • Yarmulkes
    • Tallis & Tefillin Bags
    • Gartels
    • Kittels
    • Garment Accessories
  • Music & Media
    • All Music
    • Chassidic Music
    • Children's Music
    • Classes & Shiurim
    • Concerts
    • Videos & Plays
    • Music on USB
    • Digital Downloads
  • Gifts
    • Chanukah Gifts
    • Gift Cards
    • Bar Mitzvah Gifts
    • Bat Mitzvah Gifts
    • Wedding Gifts
    • Upsherin Gifts
    • Shabbos Table Gifts
    • Judaica Gifts
    • Personalized Gifts
    • Custom Seforim Stamps
  • School Books
  1. Home
  2. Blog

When Bad Things Happen to Good People: A Complete Guide to Rabbi Kushner's Book, Its Meaning, and Who Should Read It

Add 1800Eichlers as a preferred source on Google

Few books carry the weight of When Bad Things Happen to Good People by Rabbi Harold S. Kushner. Published in 1981 and still in print more than four decades later, it has been given to mourners sitting shiva, read by rabbis and chaplains supporting families through crisis, carried into hospitals, and placed quietly beside hospital beds by people who had no other words. The book asks the question that every person of faith eventually confronts: if God is good and powerful, why do innocent people suffer? This guide covers everything a reader should know about the book before picking it up, including who wrote it, what it actually says, how it relates to Jewish thought on Emunah and Bitachon, who should read it, when to give it as a gift, and what to read alongside it. The book is available at 1800 Eichlers, 5004 13th Ave, Borough Park, Brooklyn, for $16.00.


Who Wrote When Bad Things Happen to Good People?

Rabbi Harold S. Kushner (1935-2023) was born and raised in Brooklyn, New York. He studied at Columbia University, received his rabbinical ordination from the Jewish Theological Seminary, and later earned his doctorate from the same institution. He spent most of his rabbinic career serving Temple Israel in Natick, Massachusetts, eventually becoming Rabbi Laureate there.

Kushner's interest in the problem of suffering was not theoretical. When his first-born son Aaron was three years old, the family received a diagnosis of progeria, a rare condition causing rapid and premature aging. The diagnosis meant Aaron would age at an accelerated rate, never grow beyond the height of a child, and die in his early teens. Aaron Kushner passed away at age 14.

In the years that followed, Rabbi Kushner found himself unable to accept the explanations he had been taught in seminary: that suffering is a punishment for sin, that God is testing the faithful, that everything happens for a reason, or that pain is a gift in disguise. These explanations struck him as theologically inadequate and, more importantly, deeply unkind to people in genuine pain. Out of his own experience and his years of counseling congregants through loss, he wrote the book that became one of the most widely read religious works of the twentieth century.

The book became a New York Times bestseller for many months following its publication in 1981. It has since been translated into more than fourteen languages and has sold millions of copies worldwide. Kushner went on to write more than a dozen books on Jewish thought and the challenges of living a meaningful life. He passed away in April 2023 at age 88.


What Does the Book Say? The Central Argument of When Bad Things Happen to Good People

The book opens with a question that Rabbi Kushner calls the only question that really matters: why do bad things happen to good people? He walks through the traditional answers that religious people offer, examining each one honestly and finding each one wanting, not because they are theologically careless but because they fail the people who are actually suffering.


What the Book Rejects: The Explanations That Hurt More Than They Help

Rabbi Kushner examines several categories of explanation that he argues do more harm than good when offered to people in genuine pain.

The first is the idea that suffering is a punishment for sin. This explanation, drawn from certain readings of biblical texts, places the blame on the victim. The sick person must have done something wrong. The family that lost a child must be paying for some sin. Kushner argues that this is both factually incorrect and morally offensive, as it compounds suffering with guilt.

The second is the idea that God is testing the person, that the suffering is a trial meant to build character or demonstrate faith. Kushner finds this answer cold: what kind of God deliberately inflicts pain on people to see how they respond, especially when the pain falls on children or innocents who have no power to resist it?

The third is the idea that we should not question God, that everything happens for a reason beyond human understanding, and that asking why is itself a kind of faithlessness. Kushner argues that this answer shuts down the honest conversation that grief demands. People in pain have a right to their anger and their questions.


What the Book Proposes: A God Who Suffers With Us

Kushner's response to the problem of suffering involves reconsidering one of the assumptions that makes the question so painful. He suggests that God is not the author of every misfortune. Natural illness, accident, and the random chaos of the world are not divine punishments or tests. They are the reality of living in a physical world governed by natural laws.

What God offers, in Kushner's view, is not control over every event but presence in every event. God is not the cause of suffering; God is found in the courage of people who endure it, in the community that comes together to support the mourner, in the doctor who works through the night, in the friend who shows up and stays. The book argues that asking "Where was God?" in a tragedy is best answered not by looking at the tragedy itself but at the human response to it.

This approach, while theologically distinct from traditional Orthodox positions on divine providence, has resonated with readers of every background precisely because it refuses to add theological injury to human pain. The book's most lasting contribution may be its insistence that suffering people deserve compassion first and theology second.


How When Bad Things Happen to Good People Relates to Jewish Concepts of Emunah and Bitachon

The book is rooted in Jewish experience even as it speaks to people of all faiths. Kushner draws on the Book of Job, one of the Torah's most extended wrestling matches with the problem of human suffering. Job is righteous, and his suffering is not punishment. His friends offer the traditional explanations, and the book rejects all of them. At the end, Hashem does not explain the suffering but speaks to Job directly, and Job finds comfort not in an explanation but in the encounter itself.

This structure reflects something essential in Jewish thought. The Jewish engagement with God is not passive acceptance of all events as equally deserved. It is a living, arguing, questioning relationship. The name Yisrael itself means one who struggles with God. Emunah, which is often translated as faith, is better understood as faithfulness, a commitment to the relationship even through the hardest questions.

Bitachon, trust in Hashem, is the active counterpart to Emunah. It does not mean believing that nothing bad will happen. It means trusting that God is present and that life carries meaning even when pain is real. Kushner's book, though written from a Conservative Jewish perspective, touches the same territory that the mussar and Emunah literature addresses: how do we maintain our relationship with Hashem when the world is broken?

Readers looking to explore this terrain further from within traditional Jewish thought will find the 1800 Eichlers Books Department carries a full range of Jewish Thought, Emunah, Bitachon, and Chizuk titles suited to every level and background.


Who Should Read This Book?

The book has reached readers in almost every imaginable circumstance. Over four decades, it has been read by people facing terminal illness, by parents who lost children, by survivors of tragedy, by people who felt their prayers were going unanswered, by people angry at God, and by people who had stopped believing and were trying to find their way back. It has also been read by rabbis, chaplains, doctors, nurses, social workers, and anyone whose role involves sitting with people in pain.


People in Active Grief

When Bad Things Happen to Good People is most commonly given and read during active grief. The loss of a parent, a spouse, a child, or a close friend often throws people into a crisis of meaning that touches the deepest questions of faith and justice. The book does not offer easy answers or quick comfort, but it does offer something harder to find: validation that the anger and confusion are not signs of insufficient faith but are honest human responses to real loss.


Those Supporting Someone Through Loss

Family members, close friends, and community members who are accompanying someone through grief often find themselves at a loss for what to say or do. This book helps caregivers understand what the mourner may be experiencing, what not to say (the explanations that sound like comfort but land like accusations), and what genuine presence and solidarity look like in practice. It is a tool for people who want to be helpful and are not sure how.


Rabbis, Teachers, and Pastoral Caregivers

Anyone in a pastoral role encounters the question the book addresses in almost every difficult conversation. Rabbis called to hospital bedsides, teachers supporting students who have experienced loss, chaplains in any setting, and community leaders will find in this book a framework for the conversations they need to have. The book does not replace traditional sources, but it provides accessible language for difficult terrain.


Those Questioning Their Faith After Tragedy

One of the most consistent testimonies about this book is that it has helped people maintain or return to faith after tragedy. When simplistic explanations of suffering push people away from religious life, the book's insistence that God is not the punisher but the comforter can open a door back. This is not the only Jewish approach to the question, but for many readers it has been the approach that made continued faith possible.


When Bad Things Happen to Good People as a Jewish Gift

For over four decades, this book has been one of the most trusted books to give at moments of Jewish mourning and difficulty. Its presence in Jewish homes across the denominational spectrum reflects its status as a shared communal text for the hardest moments.


During Shiva

Giving a book during shiva requires judgment. The mourner is surrounded by people, overwhelmed with food and conversation, and often not in a position to receive or process information. The right time to give a book is often slightly after the shiva week ends, in the sheloshim or the months that follow, when the visitors have gone home and the real work of grief begins. When Bad Things Happen to Good People is short enough to read in a sitting or two and direct enough to be meaningful without requiring sustained academic focus.


For Someone Facing Illness

Whether the person facing illness is the recipient or a family member, this book offers a framework for thinking about suffering that does not require explaining the illness as deserved or purposeful. It allows space for the full range of human emotion, including anger, while pointing toward resilience and meaning.


As a Gift for a Rabbi, Chaplain, or Educator

A copy of this book is a thoughtful gift for anyone in a caregiving or pastoral role. Many rabbis and chaplains have read it multiple times and find it useful at different stages of their own development and practice. A well-chosen edition makes a meaningful professional gift.


What to Read Alongside This Book

For readers who find this book meaningful and want to go deeper into Jewish thought on suffering, faith, and the relationship with Hashem, the 1800 Eichlers Books Department carries the full range of Emunah, Bitachon, and Chizuk titles.

Becoming a Ba'al Bitachon by Rabbi Yechezkel Abramov ($22.99) offers a deep practical guide to developing genuine trust in Hashem, drawn from the classical mussar sources and particularly the Sha'ar HaBitachon of the Chovos HaLevavos. Where Kushner's book addresses the emotional and theological dimensions of suffering, this title provides the traditional Jewish framework for living with trust in Hashem as a daily practice. Both books deal with the same fundamental human territory from complementary directions.

The Jewish Thought and Emunah section at 1800 Eichlers covers the full spectrum from accessible English works on faith and coping to classical mussar texts in Hebrew and English. Whatever the reader's level and background, there is a text suited to where they are.


The Book in Brief: What You Need to Know Before Reading

When Bad Things Happen to Good People is 166 pages in the paperback edition, written in clear and direct prose without academic jargon. It is organized around the central question and builds through it systematically: what the traditional answers are, why they fail, what the actual experience of suffering looks like from inside, and what a more honest and compassionate theology of suffering might say.

The book does not pretend to fully resolve the question. Kushner is explicit that he is not offering a philosophical proof or a complete theodicy. He is offering a perspective that has helped him live after the worst thing that ever happened to him, and that has helped millions of readers find their footing after their own worst things. The book is not an argument to be won or lost. It is a hand extended to someone in pain.

Its lasting influence is measured not in academic citations but in the number of times it has been pressed into the hands of a grieving father or a struggling mother or a rabbi sitting bedside with someone who is dying and asking why. More than four decades after it was first published, it continues to be that book.


Where to Buy When Bad Things Happen to Good People at 1800 Eichlers

When Bad Things Happen to Good People by Harold S. Kushner is available at 1800 Eichlers for $16.00. Publisher: Anchor Books. Format: Paperback. Pages: 166. ISBN: 9781400034727. Category: Jewish Thought (Emunah and Bitachon, Chizuk).

Free US shipping on orders over $69. Same-day delivery across the tri-state area. In-store at 5004 13th Ave, Borough Park, Brooklyn, NY 11219. Phone: (718) 874-9771. WhatsApp: 1-800-342-4537. For the complete Jewish Thought and Emunah book selection, visit the 1800 Eichlers Books Department. For the full story of 1800 Eichlers and its decades of service to the Borough Park community and Jewish families across the United States, see the 1800 Eichlers about page.


What Customers Say About 1800 Eichlers

Customers who shop for Jewish books and seforim at 1800 Eichlers describe a store with the depth of selection and the staff knowledge that makes finding the right book for a specific moment easier.

Louis R. on Yelp: "The Home Depot of Judaica in the USA. Excellent selection. The owner is always around and you can talk with him personally."

Edward Neiger on Google: "Really great selection, very friendly and knowledgeable staff and good pricing."

Julius Hersh on Google: "Great service, very helpful employees with great prices."

Jeroen Reuven B. on Yelp: "Basically a mahkollet for daily and fancier Judaica. Very good value and service."

A Google reviewer: "Love walking in there. Great service. Has everything I need and organized!"

A longtime customer on @1800eichlers Instagram: "Best store ever. Been ordering from 1800 Eichlers since the 80s!! Mazel tov!"

4.7 stars across 770 reviews. The books department at 1800 Eichlers carries titles across all areas of Jewish Thought, seforim, Emunah, Bitachon, Chizuk, and English Jewish books. Staff can advise on the right book for a specific occasion, a specific reader, or a specific moment in life.


Frequently Asked Questions About When Bad Things Happen to Good People

What is When Bad Things Happen to Good People about?

It is a book by Rabbi Harold S. Kushner about why innocent people suffer and where God is when tragedy strikes. Written after the death of his son Aaron from a rare aging disease, the book addresses the central question of theodicy: why suffering exists in a world created by a good God. It offers a compassionate response that has comforted millions of readers across all faiths for over four decades.


Who is Rabbi Harold Kushner?

Rabbi Harold S. Kushner (1935-2023) was a Conservative rabbi born in Brooklyn, New York, ordained at the Jewish Theological Seminary. He served as rabbi and Rabbi Laureate of Temple Israel in Natick, Massachusetts, and wrote more than a dozen books on Jewish thought, grief, and meaning. When Bad Things Happen to Good People became a New York Times bestseller in 1981 and has been translated into over fourteen languages.


Who should read When Bad Things Happen to Good People?

Anyone grieving a loss, anyone supporting someone through loss, anyone questioning their faith after tragedy, and anyone in a pastoral or caregiving role. The language is clear and accessible. The book is 166 pages and can be read in a single sitting. It is appropriate for readers across all Jewish denominations and religious backgrounds.


How does this book relate to Jewish concepts of Emunah and Bitachon?

The book draws on the Book of Job and the Jewish tradition of arguing with God as an expression of faith rather than faithlessness. While Kushner's theological conclusions differ from classical Orthodox positions on divine providence, his core message, that God is present in suffering and that Emunah is a living relationship rather than passive acceptance, touches the same territory addressed by the mussar and Emunah literature available in the 1800 Eichlers Books Department.


Is When Bad Things Happen to Good People appropriate for an Orthodox Jewish reader?

The book is widely read across all Jewish denominations. Orthodox readers engage with it knowing that Kushner's theological conclusions differ from traditional Orthodox positions. Many Orthodox rabbis and educators find it valuable for supporting congregants through grief, while drawing on additional traditional sources for theological grounding. It is a book about human experience first and theology second.


  • Terms of Use
  • Privacy Policy
  • Shipping Policy
  • Return Policy
  • About
  • Blog
  • Contact Us
  • Store Hours
  • Store Address
  • Bulk Orders