How to Choose a Kosher Lulav and Esrog Set
Add 1800Eichlers as a preferred source on Google
Quick Answer
Choosing a kosher lulav and esrog set for Succos involves checking four separate species: the esrog (citron fruit), the lulav (palm branch), three hadassim (myrtle branches), and two aravos (willow branches). Each species has specific halachic requirements. For the esrog, focus on species purity, an intact pitom (if applicable to your variety), a clean rind, and the oketz (stem) attached. For the lulav, confirm the tiyomes (central spine leaf) is not split at the tip. For hadassim, verify the meshulash leaf pattern. For aravos, check that leaves are intact and stems are red or white. Buy your set early and store it correctly to keep it fresh for all seven days of Succos.
Why Choosing Well Matters
The mitzvah of arba minim (four species) is commanded for all seven days of Succos. For families looking to buy lulav and etrog, order a lulav and etrog set, or find a lulav and esrog set that meets all halachic requirements, understanding what makes each species kosher is the essential starting point. Each day the set is used, each species must still meet its halachic requirements. A set that is borderline acceptable on day one may become passul by day four if not properly cared for. Buying a quality set, understanding what makes each species kosher, and knowing how to keep the set fresh are all part of fulfilling the mitzvah with care throughout the holiday.
This guide covers each species in turn, addresses the most common questions buyers have about esrog varieties and quality, and provides practical guidance on accessories, care, cost, and timing. For the complete range of lulav and esrog sets and accessories, browse the Lulav and Esrog Set collection at 1800 Eichlers.
Choosing the Esrog
The esrog is typically the most discussed and carefully selected of the four species. A quality esrog takes longer to inspect and has more variables to consider than the lulav or the other two species. Understanding what you are looking for simplifies the process considerably.
What makes an esrog kosher?
A kosher esrog must be a pure citron, not a grafted hybrid. The grafting concern is the most fundamental kashrut issue for esrogim: an esrog from a tree grafted with another citrus species is passul regardless of how beautiful it looks. In practice, the most reliable protection against this is purchasing from a reputable source with proper certification.
Beyond species purity, the requirements are:
- No significant blemishes on the majority of the esrog's surface. Small blemishes in limited areas are generally acceptable; extensive dark spots, deep cuts, or flat areas of damaged skin across most of the surface are not.
- Oketz attached at the base. The oketz is the small stem at the bottom of the esrog. If it has fallen off and the spot is smooth and healed, the esrog is generally still acceptable according to most opinions, but an esrog with its oketz present is preferable.
- Yellow in color. A fully ripe, yellow esrog is the ideal. A fully green esrog may be technically valid according to some opinions but is not preferred. An esrog that is yellow with some green remaining in areas is acceptable in most cases.
- Pitom considerations (see below).
What is the pitom and does it matter?
The pitom is the small protrusion at the blossom end of the esrog, opposite the oketz. Whether it matters depends on the esrog variety:
If the esrog grew a pitom during its development, and the pitom breaks off or is damaged at the tip, the esrog is passul. This is the most common way an esrog becomes invalid during the holiday week: the pitom, being delicate, breaks during handling or transport. Inspecting the pitom carefully before purchase and storing the esrog in a properly padded esrog box with the pitom protected is essential for varieties that grow one.
If the esrog variety naturally does not grow a pitom at all (as is the case with Moroccan, Yemenite, and some Israeli varieties), there is no pitom to break and this concern does not apply. A clean blossom end with no pitom scar or protrusion is a normal feature of these varieties.
The pitom check is simple: look at the blossom end of the esrog before purchasing. If there is a pitom, it should be firm, fully attached, and undamaged from the outer rim to its tip. If there is a small crack or the very tip has broken off, the esrog may be passul depending on the extent of the damage. Ask the seller or your rav if you are uncertain about a specific esrog.
What should I look for when buying an esrog?
Beyond the halachic requirements, experienced buyers look for these additional quality indicators when evaluating esrog kashrus (the kashrut of the esrog specifically):
- Shape: A pear-shaped or elongated esrog that tapers toward the pitom end is the classic preferred form, associated with the most beautiful esrogim. A round or bulging esrog is acceptable halachically but less aesthetically prized.
- Skin texture: A clean, bumpy rind with distinct ridges (called oketzes) that run from the base toward the pitom is characteristic of the finest esrogim. Smooth, flat, or shiny areas may indicate a different growing environment or slightly lower quality.
- Fragrance: A fresh, fragrant esrog has a distinctive citrus scent. Strong fragrance is associated with an esrog that is freshly harvested and in good condition.
- Color evenness: An evenly yellow esrog across most of its surface is ideal. Esrogim that are still partly green will generally continue to turn yellow during the holiday, but a mostly yellow esrog on purchase day is preferred.
What is the difference between Yanover, Moroccan and Israeli esrogim?
Three main varieties of esrogim are available in the Jewish community. The right choice depends largely on your family's minhag and community custom.
Yanover (Calabrian) esrogim
Yanover esrogim come from certified orchards in Calabria in southern Italy. They are the dominant choice in most Ashkenaz (non-Chassidic) communities in the United States and are also widely used in many Chassidic communities. Calabrian esrogim are known for their pure citron lineage, which has been carefully maintained in the Calabrian orchards for centuries. They typically develop a pitom, have an elongated shape, and a strongly ridged rind. Certification (hechsher) on Yanover esrogim comes from various reliable rabbinical authorities and is an important consideration when purchasing.
Moroccan esrogim
Moroccan esrogim are the traditional choice in Sephardic communities of Moroccan origin and in some other Sephardic communities. Moroccan varieties typically do not grow a pitom. They have their own distinct shape and rind character. The Moroccan minhag of esrog use has its own certification and sourcing standards. A Sephardic Jew from a Moroccan background should use the variety associated with their family and community tradition.
Israeli esrogim
Israeli esrogim come from orchards in Eretz Yisrael and are used by a wide range of communities. Some Israeli varieties grow a pitom and others do not, depending on the specific type. Israeli esrogim carry their own certification and are available in multiple sub-varieties. In years that are shemitah years (the seventh year of the Shemita agricultural cycle in Israel), Israeli esrogim carry additional halachic considerations regarding shemitah sanctity. This affects how the esrog must be treated after the holiday. If purchasing an Israeli esrog in or near a shemitah year, ask your rav about the applicable halachot.
Which variety should I choose?
The guiding principle is family and community minhag. Use the variety your family has traditionally used. If you are uncertain, ask your rav. Do not switch varieties year to year without a reason rooted in minhag; the choice of esrog variety is considered a matter of communal and family tradition.
Choosing the Lulav
The lulav is a palm branch that gives the entire mitzvah its name (netillas lulav). The most important inspection point is the tiyomes, the central doubled leaf at the top of the spine.
The tiyomes check
Run your thumb gently up the central spine of the lulav to feel whether the very top leaf is joined or split into two separate tips. A joined tiyomes is kosher. A split lulav, meaning one whose tiyomes has separated at the top, renders the lulav passul (Shulchan Aruch, Orach Chaim 645:2). This check takes seconds and should be the first thing you do when selecting any lulav etrog set or individual lulav.
Leaf condition
The leaves must be green, fresh, and supple. Brown, dry, or brittle leaves indicate a lulav that has been cut too long and has lost its moisture. The leaves should not droop significantly below the top of the spine. A lulav stored in a cool place and transported in a lulav bag retains its condition better throughout the holiday week.
Minimum size
The lulav must be at least four tefachim tall above the binding point where the hadassim and aravos are tied. In practice, commercially sold lulavim are almost always well above this minimum. The minimum becomes relevant only if someone considers trimming the bottom of the lulav.
The lulav must protrude above the hadassim
When the set is assembled, the lulav spine must extend at least one tefach above the tops of the hadassim (Shulchan Aruch, OC 650:2). The hadassim and aravos must not rise above the top of the lulav spine. Assembling the set correctly at the time of purchase is worth doing so you can verify this proportion.
Choosing Hadassim
Three branches of hadassim (myrtle) are used. The defining requirement is the meshulash pattern: three leaves growing from exactly the same node on the stem, in a triple arrangement around the branch. Most of the branch should show this triple pattern. Branches where most leaves grow singly or in pairs may not be kosher.
Beyond the meshulash pattern, look for green, intact leaves with no significant browning. Hadassim that have lost most of their leaves, or whose leaves are already turning brown at the time of purchase, will not hold up well through seven days of Succos.
Fresh hadassim are one of the things hardest to guarantee if ordering far in advance without refrigeration. When purchasing from a store, inspect the hadassim directly. When ordering online or through a set, ask about freshness and how the species are packed for shipping.
Choosing Aravos
Two branches of aravos (willow) are used. The requirements for kosher aravos are smooth-edged leaves (not serrated), red or white stems (black stems are not kosher according to most opinions), and leaves that are substantially intact. The aravos must be at least three tefachim long.
Aravos are the most perishable of the four species. They dry out quickly once cut. When purchasing, look for aravos with fully green, intact leaves and no significant browning. At the market, aravos that have been sitting out for several days may already be starting to dry.
Keep aravos in water throughout the holiday, similar to fresh-cut flowers. Many families obtain a fresh set of aravos specifically for Hoshana Rabba when the original aravos have dried during the holiday week.
How do you keep hadassim and aravos fresh?
Proper storage of the arba minim from purchase through the end of the holiday significantly affects whether the set remains kosher and beautiful for all seven days.
Before the holiday
From the time of purchase until Erev Succos, keep the lulav and hadassim away from direct heat and sunlight. Wrap the hadassim in a damp cloth or paper towel and refrigerate them. Keep the aravos in a cup of water in the refrigerator. Store the esrog in its case at room temperature, away from extremes of heat or cold.
During the holiday week
After each day's use, return the aravos to water. Wrap or cover the hadassim to slow moisture loss. Keep the esrog in its protective case after each use. A lulav carrying case or lulav bag significantly slows the drying of the hadassim and aravos during transport and storage throughout Chol Hamoed.
Arba Minim Accessories: What You Need
Beyond the four species themselves, a proper set of accessories protects the species throughout the holiday and makes daily use practical.
Esrog boxes and cases
The esrog must be protected at all times, particularly the pitom. An esrog box with a padded interior that holds the esrog securely with the pitom away from any hard surface is essential. Silver klutches (the traditional Ashkenaz esrog holder), leather esrog cases, and wooden esrog boxes all serve this function with different trade-offs of weight, durability, and cost. Browse the full range of Esrog Boxes at 1800 Eichlers for silver, leather, and wooden options in every price range, including engraved silver klutches for gifting.
Lulav holders and lulav bags
A lulav holder is the ring or clip that keeps the hadassim and aravos bound to the lulav during the netillas lulav. A lulav bag (carrying case) is the fabric sleeve that protects the full lulav bundle during transport to and from shul. Most families who walk to shul use both. Browse the complete range of Lulav Holders at 1800 Eichlers for holders and carrying cases in velvet, canvas, and other materials.
How much should a lulav and esrog set cost?
The cost of a lulav and esrog set varies depending on several factors:
- Esrog quality and grade: Top-grade esrogim with exceptional appearance, a perfectly intact pitom, clean rind, and full certification documentation cost significantly more than standard sets. A premium Yanover esrog at the top of the market is a specialized purchase; a mid-range set is suitable for most families.
- Esrog variety: Different varieties have different price ranges based on supply, certification costs, and demand within their communities.
- Whether the set is complete: A set that includes the lulav, hadassim, aravos, and esrog together typically offers better value than purchasing species individually, but individual species can also be purchased separately.
- Accessories: Esrog box, lulav bag, and lulav holder are sold separately and add to the total cost of your Succos arba minim preparation.
For current pricing across set grades and individual species, browse the Lulav and Esrog Set collection at 1800 Eichlers, which carries sets from entry-level to premium across multiple esrog varieties.
When should I order my lulav and esrog?
Order as early as possible. This is the most consistent advice from everyone who has navigated the pre-Succos arba minim market. Here is why timing matters:
- Top-grade esrogim in popular varieties and sizes sell out well before Erev Succos. If you wait until the days immediately before the holiday, you are choosing from what remains rather than from the full inventory.
- In 2026, Erev Succos falls on Friday, September 25. Yom Kippur ends on the night of September 21. The window for preparation between Yom Kippur and Erev Succos is only four days in 2026, all of which are compressed with sukkah building, cooking, and shopping. Having your arba minim ordered and received before Yom Kippur eliminates this pressure entirely.
- Engraved esrog boxes and other personalized items require additional lead time beyond standard shipping.
- Freshness of hadassim and aravos is a consideration in timing. Ordering too far in advance and having the species sit before the holiday is also a concern. 1800 Eichlers ships arba minim sets close to the holiday to maximize freshness.
For the full range of Succos items including arba minim sets, sukkah decorations, machzorim, and Yom Tov gifts, browse the Succos Department at 1800 Eichlers.
About 1800 Eichlers
1800 Eichlers is a Judaica superstore based in Borough Park, Brooklyn, serving Jewish communities across the United States and worldwide through 1800eichlers.com. The Succos collection includes arba minim sets, esrog boxes, lulav holders and bags, machzorim, sukkah decorations, sefarim, and gifts for the full holiday season.
Frequently Asked Questions About Choosing a Kosher Lulav and Esrog Set
- What makes an esrog kosher?
A kosher esrog must be a pure citron (not a grafted hybrid), have no significant blemishes on the majority of its surface, retain its oketz (stem), be yellow in color, and have its pitom intact if the variety grows one. Certification from a reliable rabbinical authority is the most reliable guarantee of species purity.
- What should I look for when buying an esrog?
Look for a clean, unblemished rind, a yellow color, an intact pitom (for varieties that grow one), an attached oketz, a classic elongated shape, and a fresh fragrance. Avoid esrogim with large dark spots, deep cuts, or extensive surface damage. Inspect the pitom carefully: it should be firm and undamaged from base to tip.
- What is the pitom and does it matter?
The pitom is the protrusion at the blossom end of the esrog. If the variety grows one and it breaks off, the esrog is passul. Varieties that naturally grow without a pitom (such as Moroccan and some Israeli types) are not affected by this concern. Check the pitom carefully before purchasing and use an esrog box with proper interior padding to protect it throughout the holiday.
- What is the difference between Yanover, Moroccan and Israeli esrogim?
Yanover (Calabrian) esrogim from southern Italy are the standard for most Ashkenaz communities. Moroccan esrogim are traditional in Sephardic communities of Moroccan origin and typically have no pitom. Israeli esrogim come from Eretz Yisrael and are used across many communities. The choice depends on your family and community minhag. When in doubt, ask your rav.
- How do you keep hadassim and aravos fresh?
Keep hadassim wrapped in a damp cloth in the refrigerator between uses. Keep aravos in a cup of water like fresh-cut flowers and refresh daily. Use a lulav bag during transport to slow moisture loss. Obtain fresh aravos for Hoshana Rabba if the original set has dried significantly during the week.
- How much should a lulav and esrog set cost?
Cost varies by esrog grade, variety, and whether the set includes accessories. Entry-level sets are affordable for families on a budget. Premium sets with top-grade esrogim cost significantly more. Accessories (esrog box, lulav bag, lulav holder) are additional. Browse current pricing in the Lulav and Esrog Set collection at 1800 Eichlers for the full range.
- When should I order my lulav and esrog?
Order as early as possible, ideally several weeks before Succos. Top-grade esrogim sell out quickly. In 2026, Erev Succos falls on Friday, September 25, only four days after Yom Kippur ends. Having your set ordered before Yom Kippur eliminates the pre-holiday rush entirely. Engraved esrog boxes require extra lead time.